I wear a size 10, D to accommodate orthotics and have a narrow left heel, and this last attribute makes it difficult for me to find shoes that fit well. Usually, the left heel will slip off. I ordered 5 shoes though Amazon.Com and the company it bought a few years ago, Zappos.com, including well-respected brands like Ecco, Dansko, Rockport, and Drew.. All were well-made, but only the Dunham shoe was narrow enough to fit well. It fit me exceptionally well, but it may be too narrow for many people. For people like me, this may be the shoe you've been looking for.The upper left part of the shoe was a bit too tight, hitting my little toe, but this loosened up after about 3-4 weeks; I'm very glad I kept them. They're solidly build with good traction, and I like the appearance. I also got used to the multi-colored laces, but you could always replace these with something else. The arch support is fair; I would try wearing these with orthotics if you need extra support. I think they're a good everyday shoe that compares very well to others in the $100-%150 price range. NOTE: I recently discovered that I have toe pain related to MTP degeneration five years after breaking that toe. The Dunhams accommodate a flat rigid orthotic. However, my doctor has recommended the highly cushioned, and more rigid Hoka One One brand for my condition (not these shoes), and I expect I'll alternate between wear those and wearing this shoe.